bypass top and left hand navigationNational Science Board   HOME     PDF     SEARCH     HELP     COMMENTS  
Science and Engineering Indicators 2004
  Table of Contents     Figures     Tables     Appendix Tables     Presentation Slides  
Chapter 5:
Highlights
Introduction
Financial Resources for Academic R&D
Doctoral Scientists and Engineers in Academia
Outputs of Scientific and Engineering Research: Articles and Patents
Conclusion
References
 
 

Academic Research and Development

PDFPrint this chapter (336K)
Introduction

Chapter Overview
Chapter Organization

Chapter Overview  top of page

The academic sector is a major contributor to the nation's scientific and technological progress, both through the education and training of scientists and engineers (see chapter 2) and the generation of new knowledge and ideas. These activities advance science and support technological innovation, which in turn enhances economic development. A strong national consensus supports the public funding of academic research, and the Federal Government still provides close to 60 percent of the necessary financial resources, although its role is diminishing. More than half of all academic research and development funds go to the life sciences, and this share increased during the past quarter century, prompting discussion about whether the distribution of funds across disciplines is appropriate.

The number of academic institutions receiving Federal support for R&D activities increased during the past 3 decades, expanding the base of the academic R&D enterprise beyond the traditional research institutions. The academic science and engineering infrastructure, both research space and research equipment, grew over the past decade. However, the percentage of total annual R&D expenditures devoted to research equipment declined.

Doctoral S&E faculty in universities and colleges play a critical role in ensuring an adequate, diverse, and well trained supply of S&E personnel for all sectors of the economy (see chapter 3). Demographic projections point to the potential for strong enrollment growth and the continuation of several trends: more minority participation, more older students, and more nontraditional students. Future trends for foreign graduate students, however, are uncertain in the wake of the events of September 11, 2001.

In this context, and driven by financial and other pressures, universities and colleges will continue to debate questions about their organization, focus, and mission. These discussions are taking place during a time when academia may be approaching a period of increasing retirements caused by an aging labor force. The extent and nature of replacement hiring into tenure-track faculty positions versus other, more temporary, positions are unresolved questions.

Until recently, positive outcomes and impacts of R&D were taken for granted; however, the R&D enterprise has begun to face demands that it devise means and measures to account for results of specific Federal R&D investments, including those for academic R&D, and for the longer term consequences of those results for valued social ends.[1]

This chapter addresses key issues of the academic R&D enterprise, such as the Federal role in supporting academic research; the distribution of funding across S&E disciplines; the breadth and strength of the academic base of the nation's S&E and R&D enterprise; research facilities and instrumentation at universities and colleges; the role of doctoral S&E faculty, including both their teaching and their research responsibilities; and research outputs in the form of refereed articles, academic patents, licenses, and spinoffs. Comparisons with other countries can be found in chapters 2 and 3.

Chapter Organization  top of page

The first section of this chapter discusses trends in the financial resources provided for academic R&D, including allocations across both academic institutions and S&E fields. Because the Federal Government has been the primary source of support for academic R&D for more than half a century, the importance of selected agencies in supporting individual fields is explored in detail. This section also presents data on changes in the number of academic institutions that receive Federal R&D support and then examines the status of two key elements of university research activities: facilities and instrumentation.

The next section discusses trends in the employment of academic doctoral scientists and engineers and examines their activities and demographic characteristics. The discussion of employment trends focuses on full-time faculty, postdocs, graduate students, and other positions. Differences between the nation's largest research universities and other academic institutions are considered, as are shifts in the faculty age structure. The involvement of women and minorities is also examined. Attention is given to participation in research by academic doctoral scientists and engineers, the relative balance between teaching and research, and Federal support for research. Selected demographic characteristics of recent doctorate holders entering academic employment are reviewed.

The chapter concludes with an assessment of two types of research outputs: scientific and technical articles measured by data from a set of journals covered by the Science Citation Index (SCI) and the Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI) and patents issued to U.S. universities. (A third major output of academic R&D, educated and trained personnel, is discussed in the preceding section of this chapter and in chapter 2.) This section looks specifically at the volume of research (article counts), collaboration in the conduct of research (joint authorship), use in subsequent scientific activity (citation patterns), and use beyond science (citations to the literature on patents). It concludes with a discussion of academic patenting and some returns to academic institutions from their patents and licenses.


Footnotes

[1]  These demands can be seen in both the Government Performance and Results Act (GPRA) of 1993 (Public Law 103-62) and the more recent U.S. Office of Management and Budget R&D Investment Criteria (see http://www.ostp.gov/html/ombguidmemo.pdf). For a discussion of research assessment in the context of the GPRA, see http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/ostp/assess/nstcafse.htm.


Previous Page Top Of Page Next Page