The nation’s 39 federally funded research and development centers (FFRDCs) spent $17.4 billion on research and development in FY 2012, according to data from the National Science Foundation (NSF).[2] This was a slight decline from the $17.8 billion spent in FY 2011 (table 1).
TABLE 1. Total and ARRA-funded R&D expenditures at federally funded research and development centers, by FFRDC: FYs 2010–12 (Dollars in thousands)
2010
2011a
2012
Funded by ARRA
Funded by ARRA
Funded by ARRA
FFRDC
Total
Amount
Percent
Total
Amount
Percent
Total
Amount
Percent
All FFRDCs
18,044,105
1,048,028
5.8
17,808,614
771,602
4.3
17,446,036
352,251
2.0
Aerospace FFRDC
44,149
0
0.0
45,827
0
0.0
39,746
0
0.0
Ames Lab.
30,836
30
0.1
32,442
311
1.0
33,853
257
0.8
Argonne National Lab.
650,504
77,017
11.8
710,435
70,627
9.9
679,387
27,426
4.0
Arroyo Ctr.
28,647
0
0.0
32,180
0
0.0
31,278
0
0.0
Brookhaven National Lab.
535,546
49,712
9.3
526,571
98,108
18.6
516,921
5,656
1.1
Ctr. for Advanced Aviation System Development
149,686
0
0.0
165,645
0
0.0
159,311
0
0.0
Ctr. for Communications and Computing
71,927
0
0.0
72,600
0
0.0
62,600
0
0.0
Ctr. for Enterprise Modernization
170,460
401
0.2
187,785
2,783
1.5
226,539
928
0.4
Ctr. for Naval Analyses
109,068
0
0.0
85,165
0
0.0
91,628
0
0.0
Ctr. for Nuclear Waste Regulatory Analyses
15,346
0
0.0
16,377
0
0.0
13,147
0
0.0
Fermi National Accelerator Lab.
402,658
19,474
4.8
420,119
26,042
6.2
412,438
23,982
5.8
Frederick National Lab. for Cancer Research
643,935
183,335
28.5
431,600
0
0.0
430,100
0
0.0
Homeland Security Studies and Analysis Institute
33,402
0
0.0
36,870
0
0.0
30,213
0
0.0
Homeland Security Systems Engineering and Development Institute
58,715
0
0.0
85,154
0
0.0
77,159
0
0.0
ID National Lab.
478,356
3,536
0.7
425,072
4,363
1.0
536,399
5,653
1.1
Jet Propulsion Lab.
1,640,341
101,205
6.2
1,543,969
24,543
1.6
1,493,613
3,746
0.3
Judiciary Engineering and Modernization Ctr.b
na
na
na
4,650
0
0.0
5,309
0
0.0
Lawrence Berkeley National Lab.
759,381
80,399
10.6
788,386
89,212
11.3
767,554
55,262
7.2
Lawrence Livermore National Lab.
1,370,747
3,624
0.3
1,424,993
6,237
0.4
1,353,454
6,170
0.5
Lincoln Lab.
789,502
NA
NA
822,358
0
0.0
873,104
272
0.0
Los Alamos National Lab.
2,505,913
139,376
5.6
2,307,197
101,814
4.4
2,056,878
13,663
0.7
National Astronomy and Ionosphere Ctr.c
13,203
0
0.0
14,317
0
0.0
na
na
na
National Biodefense Analysis and Countermeasures Ctr.
50,058
0
0.0
41,786
0
0.0
31,201
0
0.0
National Ctr. for Atmospheric Research
220,328
464
0.2
198,231
143
0.1
169,743
132
0.1
National Defense Research Institute
51,652
0
0.0
46,330
0
0.0
53,832
0
0.0
National Optical Astronomy Observatories
57,145
9,125
16.0
47,889
56
0.1
46,557
2,216
4.8
National Radio Astronomy Observatory
137,607
2,539
1.8
81,305
2,461
3.0
79,168
886
1.1
National Renewable Energy Lab.
326,652
36,383
11.1
386,539
44,063
11.4
398,873
26,984
6.8
National Security Engineering Ctr.
925,027
0
0.0
941,187
0
0.0
946,737
0
0.0
Oak Ridge National Lab.
1,538,412
134,856
8.8
1,558,073
88,611
5.7
1,553,460
95,600
6.2
Pacific Northwest National Lab.
1,116,648
112,870
10.1
1,095,923
115,508
10.5
1,033,768
59,750
5.8
Princeton Plasma Physics Lab.
83,932
6,132
7.3
84,863
4,711
5.6
81,389
778
1.0
Project Air Force
43,957
0
0.0
44,171
0
0.0
41,031
0
0.0
Sandia National Labs.
2,157,022
14,073
0.7
2,277,166
12,008
0.5
2,293,307
5,056
0.2
Savannah River National Lab.
127,160
17,175
13.5
134,530
9,961
7.4
132,357
2,158
1.6
Science and Technology Policy Institute
6,000
0
0.0
8,700
0
0.0
7,547
0
0.0
SLAC National Accelerator Lab.
354,393
32,796
9.3
327,716
46,520
14.2
329,747
8,564
2.6
Software Engineering Institute
99,334
12
0.0
107,837
26
0.0
113,371
65
0.1
Studies and Analyses Ctr.
156,000
0
0.0
156,200
0
0.0
149,150
0
0.0
Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility
90,456
23,494
26.0
90,456
23,494
26.0
94,167
7,047
7.5
na = not applicable; NA = not available.
ARRA = American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009; FFRDC = federally funded research and development center.
a R&D expenditures decreased in FY 2011 due to removal of expenditures for capital projects. Beginning with the FY 2011 survey, R&D expenditures do not include capital projects. In previous years, some FFRDCs included capital expenditures in their R&D totals. Previous years include an unknown amount of capital expenditures, estimated to be less than $500 million per year. b On 2 September 2010, the Judiciary Engineering and Modernization Center was created. c On 1 October 2011, the National Astronomy and Ionosphere Center was decertified as an FFRDC.
SOURCE: National Science Foundation, National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics, FFRDC Research and Development Survey.
FFRDCs are privately operated R&D organizations that are exclusively or substantially financed by the federal government.[3] FFRDCs provide the sponsoring federal agencies with capabilities to meet special long-term R&D needs that cannot be met as effectively by existing in-house or contractor resources. They enable agencies to use private sector resources to accomplish tasks that are integral to the mission and operation of the sponsoring agency. FFRDC organization ranges from traditional contractor-owned/contractor-operated or government-owned/contractor-operated structures to various degrees of contractor-government control and ownership. Each FFRDC is operated, managed, or administered by a university or university consortium, a nonprofit organization, or an industrial firm, either as an autonomous organization or as a separate operating unit of a parent organization. FFRDCs perform R&D for both defense and civilian applications and across a broad range of science and engineering fields.
Federal funding accounted for 97.5% ($17.0 billion) of the FFRDC’s total expenditures in FY 2012 (table 2). Between FY 2010 and FY 2012, FFRDC’s R&D expenditures were boosted by $2.2 billion in funding provided by the one-time American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA).
TABLE 2. R&D expenditures at federally funded research and development centers, by source of funds: FY 2012 (Dollars in thousands)
Source of funds
All FFRDCs
All R&D expenditures
17,446,036
Federal government
17,006,331
State and local government
39,428
Business
184,244
Nonprofit organizations
77,120
All other sources
138,913
FFRDC = federally funded research and development center.
SOURCE: National Science Foundation, National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics, FFRDC Research and Development Survey, FY 2012.
In addition to federal funding, many FFRDCs receive funding and perform work for nonfederal sponsors. However, nonfederal sources accounted for just 2.5% ($440 million) of the FFRDC total expenditures (table 2). In FY 2012, FFRDCs reported $184 million in R&D expenditures funded by businesses, $77 million funded by nonprofit organizations, $39 million funded by state and local governments, and an additional $139 million funded by all other nonfederal sources.
The type of work performed across the FFRDCs was fairly evenly distributed between basic research (35.2% of total expenditures), applied research (30.7%), and development (34.1%) in FY 2012 (table 3). However, there was much greater variation in these proportions when looking at individual FFRDCs. Ten FFRDCs (8 of them university administered) reported that basic research expenditures comprised 70% or more of their total spending, 13 FFRDCs reported that over 70% of their spending was on applied research, and 8 FFRDCs classified at least 70% of their spending as development.
TABLE 3. Total R&D expenditures at federally funded research and development centers, by character of work and FFRDC: FY 2012
FFRDC
Sponsor
Location
All R&D expenditures (US$thousands)
Basic research
(%)
Applied research
(%)
Development (%)
All FFRDCs
17,446,036
35.2
30.7
34.1
University administered
5,174,091
41.7
26.8
31.5
Ames Lab.
DOE
Ames, IA
33,853
70.6
25.6
3.7
Argonne National Lab.
DOE
Argonne, IL
679,387
44.9
27.1
28.0
Fermi National Accelerator Lab.
DOE
Batavia, IL
412,438
100.0
0.0
0.0
Jet Propulsion Lab.
NASA
Pasadena, CA
1,493,613
10.0
10.0
80.0
Lawrence Berkeley National Lab.
DOE
Berkeley, CA
767,554
73.3
26.6
0.1
Lincoln Lab.
DOD, OSD
Lexington, MA
873,104
0.0
90.7
9.3
National Ctr. for Atmospheric Research
NSF
Boulder, CO
169,743
49.1
16.4
34.5
National Optical Astronomy Observatories
NSF
Tucson, AZ
46,557
100.0
0.0
0.0
National Radio Astronomy Observatory
NSF
Charlottesville, VA
79,168
90.3
6.4
3.4
Princeton Plasma Physics Lab.
DOE
Princeton, NJ
81,389
100.0
0.0
0.0
SLAC National Accelerator Lab.
DOE
Stanford, CA
329,747
100.0
0.0
0.0
Software Engineering Institute
DOD, OSD
Pittsburgh, PA
113,371
0.0
13.2
86.8
Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility
DOE
Newport News, VA
94,167
100.0
0.0
0.0
Nonprofit administered
5,464,141
28.1
29.1
42.9
Aerospace FFRDC
DOD, Air Force
El Segundo, CA
39,746
6.7
76.5
16.9
Arroyo Ctr.
DOD, Army
Santa Monica, CA
31,278
0.0
100.0
0.0
Brookhaven National Lab.
DOE
Upton, NY
516,921
77.8
10.0
12.2
Ctr. for Advanced Aviation System Development
DOT, FAA
McLean, VA
159,311
0.0
5.1
94.9
Ctr. for Communications and Computing
DOD, NSA/CSS
Alexandria, VA
62,600
25.0
50.0
25.0
Ctr. for Enterprise Modernization
Treasury (IRS), VA
McLean, VA
226,539
0.0
5.5
94.5
Ctr. for Naval Analyses
DOD, Navy
Alexandria, VA
91,628
0.0
100.0
0.0
Ctr. for Nuclear Waste Regulatory Analyses
NRC
San Antonio, TX
13,147
0.0
100.0
0.0
Homeland Security Studies and Analysis Institute
DHS
Arlington, VA
30,213
0.0
100.0
0.0
Homeland Security Systems Engineering and
Development Institute
DHS
McLean, VA
77,159
0.0
2.4
97.6
National Biodefense Analysis and Countermeasures Ctr.
DHS
Frederick, MD
31,201
0.0
100.0
0.0
National Defense Research Institute
DOD, OSD
Santa Monica, CA
53,832
0.0
100.0
0.0
National Renewable Energy Lab.
DOE
Golden, CO
398,873
4.3
19.4
76.3
National Security Engineering Ctr.
DOD, OSD
Bedford, MA; McLean, VA
946,737
0.0
5.2
94.8
Oak Ridge National Lab.
DOE
Oak Ridge, TN
1,553,460
55.6
44.4
0.0
Pacific Northwest National Lab.
DOE
Richland, WA
1,033,768
22.4
18.2
59.5
Project Air Force
DOD, Air Force
Santa Monica, CA
41,031
0.0
100.0
0.0
Science and Technology Policy Institute
NSF
Washington, DC
7,547
0.0
100.0
0.0
Studies and Analyses Ctr.
DOD, OSD
Alexandria, VA
149,150
0.0
100.0
0.0
Industry administered
6,807,804
35.9
35.1
29.0
Frederick National Lab. for Cancer Research
NIH
Frederick, MD
430,100
11.1
88.9
0.0
ID National Lab.
DOE
Idaho Falls, ID
536,399
6.0
51.0
43.0
Judiciary Engineering and Modernization Ctr.
U.S
McLean, VA
5,309
0.0
5.6
94.4
Lawrence Livermore National Lab.
DOE
Livermore, CA
1,353,454
12.3
74.3
13.4
Los Alamos National Lab.
DOE
Los Alamos, NM
2,056,878
100.0
0.0
0.0
Sandia National Labs.
DOE
Albuquerque, NM
2,293,307
5.9
28.7
65.4
Savannah River National Lab.
DOE
Aiken, SC
132,357
5.0
50.0
45.0
DOD = Department of Defense; DOE = Department of Energy; DHS = Department of Homeland Security; DOT = Department of Transportation; FAA = Federal Aviation Administration; FFRDC = federally funded research and development center; IRS = Internal Revenue Service; NASA = National Aeronautics and Space Administration; NIH = National Institutes of Health; NRC = Nuclear Regulatory Commission; NSA/CSS = National Security Agency/Central Security Service; NSF = National Science Foundation; OSD = Office of the Secretary of Defense; VA = Department of Veterans Affairs.
SOURCE: National Science Foundation, National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics, FFRDC Research and Development Survey, FY 2012.
The statistics on FFRDC R&D presented in this report come from the FY 2012 NSF FFRDC Research and Development Survey. This annual survey is completed by FFRDC staff and administrators and collects data from FFRDCs on R&D expenditures by source of funds (federal, state and local, business, nonprofit organizations, or other), character of work (basic research, applied research, or development), and type of cost (salaries, software, equipment, subcontracts, or indirect costs). This survey has been a census of the full population of FFRDCs since FY 2001.
The full set of detailed tables from this survey will be available at http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/ffrdc/. Individual detailed tables from the FY 2012 survey may be available in advance of publication of the full report. For further information, please contact the author.
Notes
[1] Ronda Britt, Research and Development Statistics Program, National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics, National Science Foundation, 4201 Wilson Boulevard, Suite 965, Arlington, VA 22230 (rbritt@nsf.gov; 703-292-7765).
[2] The number of FFRDCs decreased from 40 to 39 in FY 2012 due to the decertification of the National Astronomy and Ionosphere Center located in Arecibo Puerto Rico on 1 October 2011.
[3] For a description of the federal guidelines and definitions governing FFRDCs, see the “General Notes” section of the NSF’s Master Government List of FFRDCs at http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/ffrdclist/gennotes.cfm. Current and previous Master Government Lists of FFRDCs are accessible at http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/ffrdclist/. The FFRDCs surveyed here include those in existence prior to October 2011, the beginning of fiscal year 2012.
National Science Foundation, National Center for Science and Engineering Statistics Federally Funded R&D Centers Report Declines in R&D Spending in FY 2012
Arlington, VA (NSF 14-308) [January 2014]