|NATIONAL SCIENCE FOUNDATION
Directorate for Social, Behavioral
and Economic Sciences
NSF 97-323 September 26, 1997
|by Carolyn F.|
women at a disadvantage in the doctoral science and engineering labor force? Has the gender gap in unemployment narrowed during the past two decades? Do marriage and children have different effects on male and female unemployment? The answers to
these questions are important to science and engineering policy makers, program administrators, and individuals in--or considering enteringthe doctoral science and engineering labor force. Statistical information needed to provide the answers
is presented here.
Trends in the Gender Unemployment Gap
In 1995, the unemployment rate for both men and women who hold doctoral degrees in science and engineering was 1.5 percent. This is in stark contrast to the situation in 1973, when Maxfield et. al. (p. 5) found, " ...the unemployment rate for women ... substantially higher than that for men (3.9 percent versus 0.9 percent)." In the intervening years, the gender gap in unemployment, measured by the ratio of female to male unemployment, steadily narrowed (chart 1).
Results of studies of the gender gap, controlling for other factors, are consistent with the premise that the gender gap in unemployment among those with doctoral science and engineering degrees is disappearing. Maxfield et al. found that in 1973 in all age groups and all degree fields, women had considerably higher unemployment rates than men. The smallest reported difference was in the field of mathematics where the rate was 1.9 percent for women, compared to 1.4 percent for men. A National Science Foundation study of factors affecting unemployment in the 1993 doctoral science and engineering population (forthcoming), found no statistically significant difference between unemployment rates for men and women, after controlling for variables such as field of degree and years since degree.
The vanishing gender gap in the doctoral science and engineering population is a reflection of a similar trend in the general population (U.S. Department of Labor, p. 32). In 1973, the unemployment rate for women in the general U.S. population, aged 20 and over, was substantially higher (4.9 percent) than that for men (3.3 percent). By the early 1980s, the gender gap in the general population had been eliminatedapproximately a decade before its disappearance in the science and engineering doctoral population.
Gender Roles and Unemployment
Traditionally, men were expected to be the primary "bread-winners" in a family and women were expected to be homemakers. These roles presumably placed greater pressure on men to settle for sub-optimal jobs to support their families and placed greater pressure on women to stay at home or, if they were forced to enter the labor force for some reason, to accept employment that did not place undue stresses on their family responsibilities. Because of these different roles, it is logical to expect marriage and children to lead to lower unemployment rates for men, but higher unemployment rates among women. This is, indeed, the situation in the doctoral science and engineering population (chart 2). In 1993, unmarried men in the doctoral population had higher unemployment rates than unmarried women, but married women had higher unemployment rates than married men. Similarly, unemployment rates were higher for men without children in the home than for women without children, but lower for men with children in the home than for women with children in the home. Controlling for other relevant variables did not change these relationships substantially (NSF, forthcoming).
In the general population, gender differences in the effect of marriage and children on unemployment are discernible, but less dramatic than those for the doctoral science and engineering population. Women without children in the home are considerably less likely to be unemployed (4.5 percent) than men without children (8.4 percent); however, women with children in the home are more likely to be unemployed (5.9 percent) than men with children in the home (5.5 percent). Among unmarried individuals, women had a substantially lower unemployment rate (6.7 percent) than men did (11.7 percent); however, married women had only a slightly lower unemployment rate (4.2 percent) than married men (5.2 percent).
Unemployed: on lay-off or not employed but searching for work (during the four week period prior to the reference date).
Labor Force: unemployed plus employed individuals.
Unemployment Rate: percent of the labor force who are unemployed. Previously reported rates were adjusted to make them more comparable to recent rates.
References and Related Publications:
For more information on doctoral unemployment, see NSF's forthcoming publication, Who is Unemployed? Factors Affecting Unemployment Among Individuals with Doctoral Degrees in Science and Engineering to be released in hard copy and on the Web (http://www.nsf.gov/statistics/).
This Issue Brief was prepared by:
Dr. Carolyn F. Shettle
For free copies of SRS Issue Briefs, write to the above address, call (301) 947-2722, or send e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org.